10. DeMarcus Ware
The greatest pure pass-rusher in franchise history, Ware terrorized quarterbacks throughout his Dallas tenure and holds the team’s all-time sack record. A nine-time Pro Bowler and four-time First-Team All-Pro, his blend of speed and power made him one of the most feared defenders of his era. He’s the modern face of Cowboys defense.
9. Tony Dorsett
A first-ballot Hall of Famer, Dorsett was a game-changing running back who helped deliver a Super Bowl and became one of the most electric ball-carriers of his generation. He was the ultimate gamer — tough, durable, and explosive — missing just a handful of games across his Cowboys career despite the punishment the position demands.
8. Michael Irvin
“The Playmaker” was the emotional heart and soul of the 1990s dynasty. A member of the famous “Triplets,” Irvin’s knack for the biggest catch in the biggest moment helped Dallas win three Super Bowls in four years. His back-to-back touchdowns in Super Bowl XXVII broke the game open and ended a 15-year title drought. Few players embodied Cowboys swagger like Irvin.
7. Randy White
Nicknamed “The Manster” — half man, half monster — White was the terrifying centerpiece of the “Doomsday Defense.” A nine-time Pro Bowler and seven-time First-Team All-Pro, he was co-MVP of Super Bowl XII and dominated the interior of the defensive line for years. Sustained excellence and championship impact make him one of the greatest defenders ever to wear the star.
6. Jason Witten
One of the greatest tight ends in NFL history, Witten was a model of consistency and toughness for a decade and a half in Dallas. An 11-time Pro Bowler, he ranks among the all-time leaders at his position in receptions and receiving yards. He never won a Super Bowl, but his durability, reliability, and production put him firmly among the franchise’s elite.
5. Larry Allen
Widely regarded as one of the greatest — and strongest — offensive linemen in NFL history, Allen was the anchor of the “Great Wall of Dallas.” An 11-time Pro Bowler and seven-time First-Team All-Pro, he dominated at both guard and tackle and paved the way for Emmitt Smith’s rushing records. His combination of size, power, and agility was almost unfair. A Hall of Famer and two-time All-Decade selection.
4. Troy Aikman
The steady hand at the wheel of the 1990s dynasty, Aikman quarterbacked the Cowboys to three Super Bowl titles in four years. He wasn’t about gaudy stats — he was about winning, precision, and playoff poise. His efficiency shined brightest on the biggest stage, earning Super Bowl XXVII MVP honors. A first-ballot Hall of Famer and the last Cowboys quarterback to hoist the Lombardi Trophy.
3. Bob Lilly
“Mr. Cowboy.” The very first draft pick in franchise history, Lilly set the standard for everything that followed. He made the Pro Bowl in each of his first eleven seasons — an almost unthinkable run of dominance — and was a cornerstone of the team’s rise to prominence and its Super Bowl VI championship. Many consider him the greatest defensive player in franchise history, and he was the first Cowboy enshrined in Canton.
2. Roger Staubach
“Captain America.” A Heisman winner who served in Vietnam before even beginning his NFL career, Staubach became the face of the Cowboys’ emergence as America’s Team. Known as “Captain Comeback” for his clutch late-game heroics — he essentially invented the “Hail Mary” — he led Dallas to two Super Bowl titles and multiple appearances. Without Staubach’s leadership and mythology, the Cowboys as we know them might not exist. The greatest quarterback in franchise history.
1. Emmitt Smith
The top spot goes to the NFL’s all-time leading rusher. Smith is the most complete answer to the “greatest Cowboy” question: he owns the league’s career rushing record, won three Super Bowls, earned both a Super Bowl MVP and a league MVP, and was the engine of the 1990s dynasty. His rare blend of vision, patience, durability, and championship production is unmatched in franchise history. Numbers, rings, and impact — Emmitt has it all. He’s the greatest Dallas Cowboy of all time.
The debate is yours
Every list like this leaves off worthy legends — Mel Renfro, Chuck Howley, Deion Sanders, Tyron Smith, Zack Martin, Bob Hayes, Drew Pearson, and more could all make a case. That’s the beauty of a franchise this rich: the “snubs” would headline most teams’ lists. So where did we get it wrong? Who’s too high, who’s too low, and who did we leave out? Drop your top ten in the comments — around here, the debate never ends.
For more Cowboys history and coverage of every DFW team, keep it locked on DFW Sports Daily.