Few positions in all of sports carry more weight than quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys. Since the franchise’s debut in 1960, “America’s Team” has been led by legends, record-breakers, and a few names fans would rather forget. So who ranks as the greatest to ever wear the star? We’re counting down the seven best Cowboys quarterbacks in franchise history — and we already know you’ll disagree with at least one spot. That’s the fun. Sound off with your own order in the comments.
7. Danny White
The unenviable job of following a legend fell to Danny White, who took over for Roger Staubach and quietly put together a strong career. White spent all of his NFL seasons in Dallas and posted a winning record as a starter, leading the Cowboys to three straight NFC Championship Games in the early 1980s. He never got over the hump to a Super Bowl, which is why he lands here rather than higher, but his consistency and winning percentage earn him a firm spot on the list.
6. Craig Morton
A first-round pick in 1965, Morton spent years learning behind Don Meredith before getting his shot, and he made it count — leading Dallas to its first-ever Super Bowl appearance. He’d later face the Cowboys in a Super Bowl as a member of the Broncos, an odd footnote to a solid Dallas tenure. Morton was a capable, tough signal-caller in an era before the passing game exploded, and he helped lay the groundwork for the dynasty years to come.
5. Don Meredith
“Dandy” Don Meredith was the original face of the franchise. He started more games than any Cowboys quarterback of the 1960s and led Dallas to its first playoff appearances, helping transform an expansion team into a contender. Meredith set the template for what it meant to be QB1 in Dallas — the spotlight, the pressure, the stardom — before going on to broadcasting fame. Pioneers matter, and Meredith was the first great one.
4. Dak Prescott
Here’s where the debates really heat up. A fourth-round pick in 2016, Prescott was never supposed to be the guy — until an injury to Tony Romo thrust him into the lineup, and he never gave the job back. He won Offensive Rookie of the Year, made multiple Pro Bowls, and in November 2025 passed Romo to become the franchise’s all-time passing leader. He also owns the most regular-season wins of any Cowboys QB not named Staubach or Aikman. The knock is the same one that follows the modern Cowboys: postseason success. Until the deep playoff runs come, he sits just outside the top three — but the counting stats say he belongs in the conversation.
3. Tony Romo
One of the great undrafted stories in NFL history, Romo went from an unknown backup to rewriting the Dallas record book. For over a decade he was the franchise’s all-time passing leader (a mark he held until Prescott passed him), and he still holds the franchise record for touchdown passes. Romo posted a better regular-season winning percentage than some of the men ranked above him and delivered countless thrilling moments. His postseason record (just 2-4) is the reason he’s third and not higher — but statistically, he’s one of the two or three best to ever do it in Dallas.
2. Troy Aikman
Now we’re in rarefied air. Aikman is the Cowboys’ last Super Bowl-winning quarterback, and he won three of them in the 1990s — becoming the first starting QB in history to capture three titles in a four-year span. A first-ballot Hall of Famer, he owns one of the highest Super Bowl completion percentages ever and still holds the franchise record for regular-season wins. Aikman wasn’t about flashy numbers; he was about winning when it mattered most. Three rings is three rings. He’s the standard by which every Cowboys QB is measured — except one.
1. Roger Staubach
“Captain America” takes the crown. Staubach didn’t even become the full-time starter until age 29, then immediately went undefeated as a starter en route to winning Super Bowl VI and earning MVP honors. Over the following seasons he won two Super Bowls, played in others, and authored some of the most iconic moments in NFL history — including the original “Hail Mary.” A member of the NFL’s 100th Anniversary All-Time Team, Staubach combined winning, clutch play, and legend-making drama like no Cowboy before or since. He’s the greatest quarterback in Dallas Cowboys history, and it’s not particularly close.
The debate is yours
Every ranking like this is an argument, and reasonable fans will shuffle these names. Is Romo really below Prescott, or should his numbers push him to No. 2? Does Aikman’s three rings top Staubach’s legend? And where does Dak end up when his career is finished? Drop your own top seven in the comments — around here, the QB debate never really ends.
For more Cowboys takes and coverage of every DFW team, keep it locked on DFW Sports Daily.