Since relocating from Minnesota in 1993, the Dallas Stars have become a Texas institution — bringing a Stanley Cup to the Lone Star State and icing some of the most talented players in hockey. From a legendary skater who became the face of American hockey to a rugged captain who defines the modern era, the Stars have a Hall of Fame–worthy history. Here’s our ranking of the eight greatest Dallas Stars of all time. The top spot is locked, but the rest is up for debate — so tell us your order in the comments.
8. Brenden Morrow
The heart-and-soul captain of the Stars for much of the 2000s, Morrow was a rugged, two-way power forward and one of the best locker-room leaders in franchise history. He spent the first 13 years of his career in Dallas, took over the captaincy from Mike Modano, and was the emotional engine of the team through a competitive era. Not the flashiest name on this list, but few embodied Stars grit like Morrow.
7. Jere Lehtinen
“The King of Little Things.” Lehtinen made defense beautiful, winning the Selke Trophy three times as the league’s best defensive forward. A model of consistency who played all 14 of his NHL seasons in Dallas, he neutralized opponents’ top lines while chipping in timely offense. He was a key member of the 1999 Cup team, and his impeccable two-way play made him one of the most quietly valuable Stars ever.
6. Ed Belfour
“The Eagle” was the goaltending backbone of the championship team. A fiery competitor, Belfour posted spectacular goals-against numbers during the Stars’ peak and was brilliant throughout the 1999 Cup run, including clutch shutouts in the biggest moments. He didn’t spend as long in Dallas as some on this list, but his impact was enormous — you don’t win a Cup without elite goaltending, and Belfour delivered exactly that.
5. Marty Turco
The greatest goaltender in franchise history by the numbers, Turco holds the Stars’ record for wins with 262 and never had a losing season in Dallas. He revolutionized the position with his puck-handling, playing almost like a third defenseman and earning a reputation as one of the smartest goalies in the league. He twice led the NHL in goals-against average and save percentage, and kept the Stars competitive through leaner years. A franchise original who changed how goalies play.
4. Sergei Zubov
One of the most underrated defensemen in NHL history, Zubov was the Stars’ quiet metronome on the blue line — poised, brilliant, and impossible to rush. He was the franchise’s all-time leading scorer among defensemen and an integral part of the 1999 Cup team, leading all skaters in that playoff run with a plus-13 rating. His distinctive number 56 hangs in the rafters at American Airlines Center, a fitting tribute to a Hall of Famer who controlled games without ever needing the spotlight.
3. Derian Hatcher
The captain who lifted the Cup. Hatcher was the towering, punishing anchor of the “big four” defensive corps that carried Dallas to the 1999 championship. His physical pairing wore down opposing stars — most famously helping neutralize Colorado’s high-powered attack in the 1999 Conference Finals. As the first American-born captain to hoist the Stanley Cup, Hatcher holds a special place in both franchise and hockey history. Toughness, leadership, and a ring: the complete package.
2. Jamie Benn
The modern face of the franchise. A steal as a fifth-round draft pick, Benn has been a cornerstone since his 2009 debut, blending power and skill like few others. He won the Art Ross Trophy in 2015 as the league’s leading scorer and has long served as the team’s captain and physical, emotional leader. He ranks near the top of nearly every franchise offensive category and restored Dallas’s contender credibility for a new generation. A true Stars legend still writing his story.
1. Mike Modano
There was never any doubt. Mike Modano is the greatest Dallas Star of all time — and one of the greatest American-born players in the history of the sport. Nicknamed “Superman” for the way his jersey seemed to flow like a cape as he blew past defenders, Modano combined breathtaking skating with elite finishing to become the face of the franchise for two decades.
He’s the Stars’ all-time leading scorer, held the record as the highest-scoring American-born player in NHL history, and was the offensive heartbeat of the 1999 Cup run. Beyond the stats, he was the player who taught an entire market to love hockey, selling out arenas and growing the game across Texas. His number 9 is retired, a statue of his likeness stands at American Airlines Center, and he was enshrined in the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2014. Modano isn’t just the greatest Star — he’s a Dallas sports icon on par with Dirk Nowitzki and Emmitt Smith.
The debate is yours
Modano at the top is beyond argument, but the rest is fair game. Is Benn really No. 2 over the Cup-winning legends? Where do Belfour and Turco rank against each other in net? And did we leave off a favorite like Joe Nieuwendyk, Tyler Seguin, Neal Broten, or Jason Robertson? Drop your own top eight in the comments — around here, the debate is half the fun.
For more Stars history and coverage of every DFW team, keep it locked on DFW Sports Daily.